Since Erik ten Hag took the helm at Manchester United in 2022, his reign has been marked by a mix of promise, challenge, and gradual progress. While Ten Hag’s tenure has not been without its hurdles, the Dutchman has instilled tactical discipline, revitalized youth development, and delivered key silverware. However, whether these improvements are sufficient to restore Manchester United’s dominance remains a subject of debate.
Early Promise and Tactical Restructuring
Upon his arrival, Ten Hag set out to implement a clear tactical structure aimed at transforming United’s playing style into a cohesive, possession-based, high-pressing system. Drawing from his experience at Ajax, where he guided a young squad to impressive domestic and European results, Ten Hag brought in key players such as Lisandro Martínez, Antony, and André Onana, all of whom had previously thrived under his management.
In his debut season, United showed glimpses of tactical discipline, blending a solid defensive shape with patient build-up play. Notably, the team claimed its first major silverware under Ten Hag by winning the EFL Cup in early 2023, marking United’s first trophy in six years. His ability to foster a team spirit and his focus on a defined tactical approach were commendable efforts during a time when the club had been struggling for identity(
Youth Development: A Key Strength
One of Ten Hag’s standout qualities has been his ability to nurture young talent. Under his leadership, emerging stars like Alejandro Garnacho and Kobbie Mainoo have flourished. Garnacho, known for his electrifying pace and flair, has quickly become a fan favorite. Mainoo, meanwhile, has shown maturity beyond his years, playing pivotal roles in important matches(
Football Foyer). Ten Hag’s reputation for fostering young players was a hallmark of his success at Ajax, where he nurtured world-class talents like Matthijs de Ligt and Frenkie de Jong, and he has brought this approach to Manchester United.
Looking forward, Ten Hag continues to integrate promising prospects into the first team, positioning United as a club that builds for the future by focusing on the development of young talent.
Tactical Inconsistencies and Defensive Struggles
However, Ten Hag’s reign has not been without its struggles. A recurring issue throughout his time in charge has been defensive inconsistency. While United have delivered impressive wins, such as the FA Cup triumph over rivals Manchester City, they have also suffered heavy defeats in league matches. This lack of consistency, particularly in high-stakes games against top-six rivals, has raised concerns about United’s ability to mount a serious title challenge(
Ten Hag’s attempts to refine United’s tactical identity have often been disrupted by injuries to key players. Notably, the team’s defensive frailties have been exposed, especially in games where United have faced heavy pressure. André Onana, brought in to replace David de Gea as United’s new goalkeeper, struggled at times during his first season, contributing to the team’s defensive issues(
Transfer Market Movements: Strategic or Limiting?
The Dutch manager’s transfer strategy has also drawn mixed reviews. Ten Hag’s affinity for players he worked with at Ajax has led to the acquisitions of Martínez, Antony, and Onana. This Ajax-centric approach, while designed to foster tactical familiarity, has raised concerns about the club’s over-reliance on a specific network of players. However, recent signings like Rasmus Højlund, who provides a youthful and dynamic presence in attack, suggest that United are broadening their recruitment strategy(
While Ten Hag’s preference for players who understand his tactical system is understandable, the reliance on former Ajax players may limit United’s ability to diversify its squad with talents from different tactical backgrounds.
Achievements Despite Challenges
Despite the defensive inconsistencies and transfer questions, Ten Hag has delivered success at Old Trafford. Securing both the EFL Cup and FA Cup in back-to-back seasons, including a memorable victory over Manchester City, has offered tangible proof of his capabilities as a manager. Winning trophies amidst a transitional phase for the club has given United fans hope of a return to glory(
Additionally, United managed to qualify for the Europa League, a commendable feat considering the injury-plagued nature of the 2023/24 season. This achievement demonstrated Ten Hag’s ability to navigate adversity and his tactical acumen in managing a depleted squad(
The Road Ahead: 2024/25 and Beyond
As United gear up for the 2024/25 season, the expectations surrounding Ten Hag are immense. With an enhanced coaching staff, an overhauled squad, and the backing of the Ineos ownership group, the Dutchman has the resources to further solidify his tactical vision. However, this upcoming season will be critical for Ten Hag to demonstrate that his philosophy can not only win trophies but also make United a dominant force domestically and in Europe.
Improvement in matches against top-tier opposition, especially in the Premier League, will be a defining factor. United must demonstrate greater consistency in key fixtures if they are to mount a serious challenge for the league title.
Conclusion: A Mixed but Promising Legacy
Erik ten Hag’s tenure at Manchester United has been a mixture of progress, setbacks, and hope. His tactical restructuring, focus on youth development, and ability to deliver key trophies are all significant positives. Yet, the lingering issues of defensive inconsistency and tactical adaptability leave questions about United’s ability to reclaim their place as perennial title contenders.
The 2024/25 season presents an opportunity for Ten Hag to address these challenges and continue building on the foundations he has laid. With a further strengthened squad and renewed focus, the Dutchman now has the chance to firmly establish himself as the man capable of leading Manchester United back to the pinnacle of English and European football.
As the new season kicks off, the sleeping giant that is Manchester United waits to see if Ten Hag can finally bring the club back to its former glory.